Mathematical diagrams

There’s no excuse for any authors to be satisfied with less than perfection in their diagrams – for simple diagrams at least. Software, both commercial and open-source, can now produce diagrams of extraordinarily high quality. But I keep coming across published books where the excellence of the exposition is let down by the poor quality of the diagrams. In one book (which I will not name), a graph claiming to be a sine curve seemed to be made up of half ellipses. As a pretty figure it was quite attractive, but as a “sine curve” it was atrocious. Since when did a sine curve allow a vertical tangent?

Lately I’ve been reading some books and articles about elliptic curves and their application to public-key cryptography. And again, some books, excellent in every other way, get sloppy with their diagrams. I have one book where the numbers and labels on the figures are in such a big ugly font as to ruin the graphs, and in another book one of the figures, purporting to be of an elliptic curve y^2=x^3+ax+b, is not even symmetrical about the x-axis.

One of the best graph drawing software (for 2-dimensional graphs, although there are extensions to 3-dimensions) is the PStricks package of \LaTeX. This allows for plotting, of the placement of all sorts of curves, lines, arrows, and text on a figure, all nicely integrated into the \LaTeX environment. Now, elliptic curves, being defined implicitly, are not particularly well suited to being plotted as graphs of the form y=f(x). But implicit plotting, as provided by every mathematical software I know, is clumsy and memory intensive. Generally implicit plotting of, say, f(x,y)=0 works by creating the three dimensional structure z=f(x,y), and then plotting the plane z=0.

However, an elliptic curve can be easily plotted by considering the intervals for which x^3+ax+b is positive, and graphing y=\sqrt{x^3+ax+b} and y=-\sqrt{x^3+ax+b}. Using PStricks, I produced the following diagram illustrating addition on an elliptic curve:

Addition law on an elliptic curve

This diagram was created with the following \LaTeX code:

     {x dup mul 2 sub x mul sqrt}
     {x dup mul 2 sub x mul sqrt}
     {x dup mul 2 sub x mul sqrt neg}
     {x dup mul 2 sub x mul sqrt neg}
  \rput(-1,-1.2){\large $P$}
  \rput(.2,-.2){\large $Q$}
  \rput[l](2.2,-2){\large $R=P+Q$}

I cheated slightly here: the elliptic curve used was y^2=x^3-2x which has the nice property that on the curve (-1,-1)+(0,0)=(2,-2); that is, all the coordinates are integers. The plot shown simply shifts the x-axis a bit. The problem is learning PStricks, and for plotting, as you see, learning some PostScript, which uses a stack system. Thus

x dup mul 2 sub x mul sqrt

has the following meaning:

  1. Take a value x.
  2. Duplicate it
  3. Multiply the last two values
  4. Subtract 2 from the result
  5. Multiply by x
  6. Take the square root

At the cost of a little work, superb diagrams can be produced.

Read about PostScript mathematics at and about pstricks at

The AIM Network

The Australian Independent Media Network


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 52 other followers